Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Archive for the ‘Polemics’ Category

I say this as Romney gives his closing speech. I’m disappointed in the debate and in myself for not suspecting it to be a rehash of campaign ads and speeches. Granted, I have not been alive long enough to have experienced a plethora of presidential debates, but I have been alive long enough to recognize what I have already heard several times over, with little detail, barely any citation, and no originality (unless you count making a campaign ad spew out more fake cheese than Velveeta).

Jim Lehrer is a disappointment. A moderator must never let anyone speak above him and not back down on a decision when it is time to move on. Otherwise, what are you there for?!? Yes, there has been some substance on every topic but in my opinion most topics the candidates debated have been framed with script. I happen to believe the moderator must shake up the debaters and get at what they actually believe and would actually do by eliciting ad hoc moments. The race for the presidency is when candidates should discuss their ideas in detail before the election, and the moderator shouldn’t let them exaggerate with hypotheticals of November 5th or January 20th.

If you have a completely divergent opinion from mine, I guess I would have to start by saying: yes I have been paying attention. But I have debated point by point on farm bills in the past and I do not want to waste my time on something equally exciting. I will admit this, Romney brought his A game and Obama his C. I refer to their styles and not their substance.

Is it the structure of the debate? Can so many complicated issues be compressed in an hour and a half? Maybe the debate should have had been in two parts so more information could be vetted from the two candidates. Ultimately, I should not look at this debate on how it made an impression on me but on the general public. As this moment, the general consensus seems to side with Romney winning the debate (looking at CNN).

Looking at recent history, winning a debate does not at all guarantee election; just ask Kerry. But you really know who the winners and losers are when more and more of the public starts adopting the views of one candidate over the other. I say winners and losers, not winner and loser, as more and more people are impacted by the choices, or lack thereof, we all make. The substance both candidates could have delved deeper in the debate is the nature of government itself. Both candidates often touched on it, but both have not said anything more illuminating than what I have heard in the past several years. Neither candidate would ever discuss the following:

  • The outsourcing of manufacturing jobs is actually a typical trait of societies transitioning from a modern economy (industry-based) to a post-modern economy (service-based). These are the reasons. Here are some ways to develop a 21st Century industrial based economy in addition to the service-based.

Both political party’s rhetoric may have side comments, mostly some kind of small stop-gap measure, but never ever have I heard a politician acknowledging the transitional nature of a modern to post-modern economy. And forgive me if I do not go in detail myself on why economies change from industry to service. I’m sure a little bit of good research can give you a quick overview of it (I might just do it myself when I have the time). Yet, I hear simple explanations all the time in academic circles most notably architecture, economics, history, and sociology with many comments dating back since the 1950’s. The issue of outsourcing jobs can’t be solved unless public policy addresses and reflects on the mechanisms in which it exists.

Advertisements

Read Full Post »

Logical Fallacies

Ever frustrated that you can’t win an argument or were too shy to argue for or against a point in an intellectual conversation with or without alcohol? Well, this may help you out. Here are a list of logical fallacies (BS that sounds logical but is not).

The Top 20 Logical Fallacies

Logical Fallacies from the Constitution.org Website

Read Full Post »